The federal record-keeping rule turns on one question, who counts as a producer, and a court has answered only half of it.
Section 2257 of the federal criminal code makes producers of sexually explicit images keep records proving that everyone depicted was an adult. The fight is over one word: producer.
The regulation, 28 CFR 75.1, splits producers in two, and a primary producer is whoever films, photographs or creates the image. A secondary producer produces, assembles, publishes, duplicates, reproduces or reissues material intended for commercial distribution that contains such an image, and the same person can be both.
The same section lists who doesn’t count as a producer when their activity stops there:
Read on its own terms, the line falls between hosting and selecting, and that line decides which side of the rule a site lands on. Storing what others post without choosing or changing it sits outside the definition, while assembling and publishing material yourself sits inside it.
In 2020 the Third Circuit gave the Free Speech Coalition a partial win, which the coalition summarized for its members in a post that spells out what changed and what didn’t. Random FBI inspections are over. The FBI can no longer demand access to records without a warrant. The law itself still stands. The coalition’s advice was to keep every record the statute requires.
The court assumed the secondary-producer requirements were unconstitutional but didn’t decide the point, because no secondary producer was a party to the case. That leaves a gap. A publisher that relies on that assumption is relying on a sentence, not a ruling.
The rule covers visual depictions, so a text-only site is outside it. This is a summary, not legal advice.